Rooted in tradition. Connected in faith.
Bible StudyTheology

Why Does God Allow Suffering if He Is Loving and All-Powerful? — Orthodox Bible Study

LISTEN · കേൾക്കാം

Listen to this article

English audio for this article is not available yet.

Listen to this article

Text-to-speech is unavailable in this browser.

100 Orthodox Believer Questions — Question 21

Rev. Fr. Johnson Punchakonam

Key Scriptures: Genesis 3:16–19; Job 1–2; Psalm 34:18; Isaiah 53:3–5; Luke 13:1–5; John 9:1–3; John 11:32–44; Romans 5:3–5; Romans 8:18–39; 2 Corinthians 12:7–10; Revelation 21:1–4.

Introduction

Why do innocent children suffer? Why do faithful Christians experience illness, accidents and loss? The Orthodox Church does not offer a simple explanation for every tragedy. It proclaims a God who enters suffering in Jesus Christ, defeats death through His Resurrection and promises creation’s restoration. Suffering is not automatically punishment for personal sin.

Did God create suffering?

Genesis 1 describes creation as good. Genesis 3 and Romans 5:12 connect humanity’s fallen condition with suffering and death. But an individual’s illness or disability must not be attributed to their personal wrongdoing. The fallen condition of creation and individual guilt are not the same.

Is suffering always caused by personal sin?

In John 9:1–3 Jesus rejects the disciples’ attempt to blame a man’s blindness on his or his parents’ sin. In Luke 13:1–5 Jesus rejects the assumption that victims of tragedy were worse sinners than others. Our response to suffering should begin with compassion, not accusation.

The Book of Job

Job is portrayed as righteous, yet suffers loss of family, possessions and health. His friends wrongly insist that hidden sin must explain his suffering. The book challenges simplistic explanations and teaches humility before the mystery of God.

Human freedom and evil

Human freedom makes love and moral responsibility possible but can be misused through violence, exploitation and injustice. God’s permission of freedom is not approval of evil. Human choices, however, do not explain every natural disaster, genetic illness or other tragedy.

Where is God in suffering?

In the Incarnation, the Son of God became truly human and experienced betrayal, grief, suffering and death. Isaiah 53 presents the suffering servant. The Cross reveals God’s solidarity with suffering humanity; the Resurrection reveals that suffering and death will not ultimately prevail.

Why did Jesus weep?

John 11:35 says Jesus wept at Lazarus’s tomb, although He would raise Lazarus. Christ’s tears show genuine compassion. Sometimes faithful pastoral care means listening and remaining present rather than offering a quick explanation.

Can suffering become meaningful?

Romans 5:3–5 describes endurance, character and hope growing through affliction; James 1:2–4 speaks of perseverance. These passages do not mean that suffering is intrinsically good or that God deliberately sends every tragedy as a lesson. Grace can bring transformation even amid pain.

Paul’s thorn in the flesh

In 2 Corinthians 12:7–10 Paul describes an affliction and his repeated prayer for its removal. Its precise nature is uncertain. He learns that divine grace is sufficient. This does not mean refusing medicine or assistance: prayer, healthcare and support can belong together.

Is illness divine punishment?

Scripture occasionally speaks of discipline in particular contexts, but does not permit Christians to diagnose every illness as punishment. Jesus’ healing ministry models compassion. The Holy Mystery of Anointing of the Sick offers prayer for healing, forgiveness and strength, not an accusation against the sick person.

When God seems silent

The Psalms include honest lament. Psalm 13 asks how long God will seem distant. Faith does not require pretending that pain is easy. Prayer may be a cry for help, grief and unanswered questions.

Church Fathers

St. Athanasius, On the Incarnation, links Christ’s saving work with the defeat of corruption and mortality. St. John Chrysostom urges endurance, charity and trust amid hardship. St. Isaac the Syrian emphasizes divine compassion; St. Gregory of Nyssa reflects on grief and resurrection. No single explanation accounts for every instance of suffering.

The Church’s response

Matthew 25:35–40 calls believers to care for those who hunger, thirst, suffer illness or imprisonment. The Church should pray, listen, visit, provide practical support and defend human dignity. Christian compassion must be more than an explanation of pain.

Will suffering end?

Revelation 21:1–4 promises the end of death, mourning and pain. Romans 8:18–25 portrays creation awaiting liberation. The Christian hope is the resurrection of Christ and the renewal of creation, not merely better endurance of suffering.

Discussion questions

Why does Jesus reject blame in John 9? What does Job teach about simplistic explanations? Can freedom explain natural disasters? What do Christ’s tears reveal? How can grace transform suffering without making suffering good? What can churches do for grieving families? How does the Resurrection give hope?

Conclusion

God does not reveal the reason for every tragedy, but in Christ He has not abandoned humanity. The Cross reveals God’s entry into our suffering; the Resurrection declares that suffering will not have the final word. We are called to become instruments of divine compassion.

Closing prayer

O Lord Jesus Christ, compassionate Savior and Healer of souls and bodies, look with mercy on all who suffer. Comfort those who mourn, strengthen the sick, protect the vulnerable and give hope to the abandoned. Grant wisdom and compassion to physicians, nurses, chaplains and caregivers. Teach us to carry one another’s burdens. Through the prayers of St. Mary, the Mother of God, St. Thomas the Apostle and all Your saints, surround us with Your mercy. Amen.

FROM THE ORTHODOX TV ARCHIVE

Love God & Love Life.

Original publication

PASS IT ON

Share this reflection.

Email