LISTEN · കേൾക്കാം
Listen to this article
English audio for this article is not available yet.
100 Orthodox Believer Questions — Question 3
Rev. Fr. Johnson Punchakonam
The question and the Orthodox answer
If Jesus is truly God, why did He pray to the Father (Mark 1:35; Luke 6:12; John 17; Matthew 26:39)? The Malankara Orthodox answer is that the eternal Son is distinct from the Father and truly assumed complete humanity. His prayers are genuine acts of the one incarnate Son, revealing both His eternal filial communion and His authentic human obedience. He did not cease to be divine, and He was not a second human person alongside the Word.
1. Trinity: distinction without division
John 1:1 says the Word was with God and was God. The Greek Ἐν ἀρχῇ ἦν ὁ λόγος ... καὶ ὁ λόγος ἦν πρὸς τὸν θεόν, καὶ θεὸς ἦν ὁ λόγος distinguishes the Word from the Father while affirming His divinity. John 17:5 speaks of glory shared with the Father before the world existed. The Father, Son and Holy Spirit are three distinct divine Persons, not three gods and not three roles of one Person. Their one divine essence is not divided by the Son's prayer.
2. Incarnation and Philippians 2
John 1:14 declares that the Word became flesh. Philippians 2:6–8 speaks of μορφῇ θεοῦ (morphē theou, form of God), ἑαυτὸν ἐκένωσεν (heauton ekenōsen, He emptied Himself), and μορφὴν δούλου λαβών (morphēn doulou labōn, taking the form of a servant). The passage describes voluntary self-humbling through assuming the servant's condition, not the loss of divine nature. The Son assumed a real human body, rational soul, mind, and human experience, without sin. Thus His prayer is neither a staged performance nor evidence that He is merely a creature.
3. Oriental Orthodox Christology: one incarnate Word
The Cyrilline expression μία φύσις τοῦ θεοῦ λόγου σεσαρκωμένη (mia physis tou Theou Logou sesarkōmenē) means 'one incarnate nature of God the Word.' Within the Oriental Orthodox tradition it safeguards the unity of the incarnate Christ while affirming the fullness and continuing reality of divinity and humanity without confusion or separation. Miaphysitism must not be equated with the absorption of humanity into divinity. The subject of Christ's divine and human experiences is the one incarnate Son, not two separate personal subjects. The 1990 Eastern Orthodox–Oriental Orthodox agreed statement documents important convergence while not itself establishing full communion.
4. St. Cyril of Alexandria and Ephesus
In his Third Letter to Nestorius and its anathemas, St. Cyril insists on the personal union of the Word with His flesh. Anathema 2 addresses this union; anathema 4 rejects dividing scriptural sayings between two distinct persons; anathema 10 confesses the incarnate Word as High Priest; anathema 12 attributes suffering in the flesh to the Word. Thus the one who prays, suffers and dies humanly is truly the eternal Son. These distinctions do not make the divine essence passible. The Council of Ephesus (431) defended the unity of Christ and the confession of Mary as Theotokos; the precise conciliar status and reception of individual anathemas require historical care.
5. Gethsemane: exegesis of Luke 22:42
The Greek prayer is Πάτερ, εἰ βούλει, παρένεγκε τοῦτο τὸ ποτήριον ἀπ’ ἐμοῦ· πλὴν μὴ τὸ θέλημά μου ἀλλὰ τὸ σὸν γινέσθω. Pater means Father; potērion, cup, evokes impending suffering and Old Testament cup imagery (Isaiah 51:17; Jeremiah 25:15); thelēma means will or what is desired; ginesthō means let it be done. Matthew 26:38 and Mark 14:33 portray real anguish. Christ freely offers genuine human obedience to the Father. This is not a quarrel between two gods or a proof of two separate persons in Christ. The terminology of willing and operation developed differently in later Greek and Syriac theological controversies; one should not anachronistically attribute an identical technical formula to every Father.
6. John 17: the High Priestly Prayer
John 17:1–5 concerns Christ's glorification and His pre-existent glory with the Father; verses 6–19 concern the disciples' protection and sanctification; verses 20–26 concern future believers and unity. John 17:3 calls the Father the only true God, but must be read alongside John 1:1, 5:23, 17:5 and 20:28. The prayer distinguishes the Father and Son without denying the Son's divinity. John 17:21 calls believers to unity by grace; Christians do not thereby become additional divine Persons. Parish divisions, factionalism and pride contradict this call.
7. Hebrews 5:7–9: prayers, tears and obedience
Hebrews describes Christ offering δεήσεις τε καὶ ἱκετηρίας (deēseis te kai hiketērias, prayers and supplications) μετὰ κραυγῆς ἰσχυρᾶς καὶ δακρύων (meta kraugēs ischyras kai dakryōn, with loud cries and tears). Verse 8 uses ἔμαθεν (emathen, learned) of obedience through suffering. This refers to His lived human experience, not a transition from sin or divine ignorance. Hebrews 4:15 affirms His sinlessness; 7:25 describes His intercession. He prays as the incarnate High Priest who accomplishes redemption, not because He Himself needs redemption.
8. 'The Father is greater than I' and 'I and the Father are one'
John 14:28 must be read with Philippians 2:6–11 and the whole Johannine witness: the incarnate Son voluntarily assumes the servant's condition without becoming inferior in divine essence. John 10:30 reads ἐγὼ καὶ ὁ πατὴρ ἕν ἐσμεν (egō kai ho patēr hen esmen). The neuter singular hen ('one') and plural esmen ('we are') are consistent with profound unity and personal distinction. Context matters: the saying concerns the Father's and Son's work of preserving the sheep; it should not be reduced to a grammatical proof detached from the Gospel.
9. Historical and Syriac patristic witnesses
St. Ignatius of Antioch, Letter to the Ephesians 7 and 18, confesses Christ's divinity and real human birth and suffering. St. Athanasius, Orations Against the Arians III, defends the Son's divinity while interpreting passages concerning His human limitations. Nicaea (325) confesses the Son begotten not made, of one essence with the Father; Constantinople (381) further articulates the Nicene faith. St. Cyril and Ephesus (431) safeguard the one incarnate subject. St. Severus of Antioch (sixth century), in letters and homilies, continues the Cyrilline concern that Christ not be divided into two personal subjects. Syriac terminology such as qnomo needs contextual treatment, not automatic equation with modern English 'person.'
10. Ten objections and answers
Was Jesus praying to Himself? No: the Son addresses the distinct Person of the Father. Did He need prayer because He lacked divinity? No: prayer expresses His real human life and communion. Was He inferior? Not in divine essence; His servant-condition was voluntary. Did He possess a separate human personal subject? No: one incarnate Word assumed complete humanity. Was Gethsemane theatrical? No: His sorrow was real. Were Father and Son in divine conflict? No: the one incarnate Son offers genuine human obedience. Did 'My God, why have you forsaken me?' indicate a broken Trinity? No: Matthew 27:46 quotes Psalm 22 within real human suffering. Did the Incarnation end His divinity? No. Does intercession imply an unloving Father? No: see John 3:16. May Christians pray to Jesus? Yes: the Church worships the one Triune God and invokes Christ directly in the Jesus Prayer.
11. Pastoral and liturgical application
Christ's prayer teaches that prayer is communion, not merely a request for things. Gethsemane permits believers to bring genuine fear and sorrow before God while seeking faithful obedience. Hebrews 4:15–16 offers comfort in suffering without claiming every painful event is God's will. John 17 challenges parish factionalism and invites reconciliation. Romans 5:12–19 contrasts Adam's disobedience with Christ's faithful obedience. In the Holy Qurbana the Church approaches the Father through the Son in the Holy Spirit, celebrating the saving work of the one incarnate Lord.
12. Seven-day prayer exercise
Day 1, Mark 1:35: make time for silent prayer. Day 2, Luke 6:12: pray before a decision. Day 3, Matthew 26:39: bring fears honestly before God. Day 4, Hebrews 5:7–9: reflect on costly obedience. Day 5, John 17:20–23: pray for Church unity. Day 6, Philippians 2:5–11: practice humility. Day 7, Luke 23:46: entrust your life and family to God.
13. Group discussion
1. How can the Son address the Father without dividing the one God? 2. What does John 1:1 contribute to John 17? 3. What does kenosis mean in Philippians 2? 4. Why is Christ's complete humanity essential? 5. What does St. Cyril mean by the one incarnate Word? 6. Why is miaphysitism not Eutychianism? 7. What does the cup signify in Gethsemane? 8. How do we understand Christ's human obedience? 9. How does Hebrews 5 portray His priesthood? 10. What does John 17 demand of divided parish communities?
14. Documented sources
Scripture: Mark 1:35; Luke 6:12; Luke 22:39–46; Matthew 26:36–46; John 1:1–14; John 5:19–23; John 10:30; John 14:28; John 17; John 20:28; Philippians 2:5–11; Hebrews 4:15–16; 5:7–9; 7:25; Romans 5:12–19. Patristic: Ignatius of Antioch, Letter to the Ephesians 7,18; Athanasius, Orations Against the Arians III; Cyril of Alexandria, Third Letter to Nestorius, anathemas 2,4,10,12; Cyril, On the Unity of Christ and Commentary on John; Severus of Antioch, Cathedral Homilies and letters; Gregory Nazianzen, Epistle 101. Councils: Nicaea 325, Constantinople 381, Ephesus 431. Further reading: https://www.newadvent.org/fathers/3810.htm ; https://www.newadvent.org/fathers/2816.htm ; https://orthodoxjointcommission.wordpress.com/2013/12/14/st-cyrils-third-letter-to-nestorius/ ; https://www.ecupatria.org/documents/second-agreed-statement-1990/ . These references identify texts for independent checking; particular historical formulations must be assessed in context.
Conclusion and closing prayer
Jesus prayed because He is the eternal Son who truly became human. His prayer reveals His relationship with the Father and His genuine human obedience, not inferiority of divine essence or division into two persons. The One who prayed in Gethsemane is the One through whom all things were created. O Lord Jesus Christ, eternal Son of God, teach us sincere prayer, faithful obedience, humility, and unity. Comfort the suffering, heal divisions, and draw us into communion with the Father, Son and Holy Spirit, one true God. Amen.
FROM THE ORTHODOX TV ARCHIVE
Love God & Love Life.
PASS IT ON
Share this reflection.
