LISTEN · കേൾക്കാം
Listen to this article
English audio for this article is not available yet.
100 Orthodox Believer Questions — Question 5
Rev. Fr. Johnson Punchakonam
The question and Orthodox answer
If God is love and all-powerful, why do children suffer, wars destroy lives, and disasters strike? This is the problem of evil. The Malankara Orthodox Church teaches that God created the world good, is not the author of moral evil, and does not abandon creation. Human misuse of freedom, mortality, corruption and natural processes contribute to suffering, but none explains every tragedy. Christ enters suffering, defeats death and promises creation's renewal. We must never accuse a particular victim of hidden sin.
1. Forms of evil
Moral evil involves wrongdoing such as violence, betrayal and injustice; natural suffering includes disease, earthquakes and disasters; existential suffering includes grief, loneliness and fear. Freedom explains some moral evil but does not by itself explain childhood cancer or earthquakes. A fallen world is a theological account of the human condition, not a scientific cause assigned to each illness.
2. Genesis: creation and the Fall
Genesis 1:31 calls creation טוֹב מְאֹד (tov me'od), very good. Matter and the body are not evil. Genesis 2–3 presents human responsibility, disobedience, alienation and mortality. Romans 5:12 connects sin and death. Orthodox teaching on ancestral sin emphasizes inherited mortality and a wounded condition, not the personal guilt of newborn children for Adam's individual act. The image of God remains in humanity.
3. Isaiah 45:7 in Hebrew and Greek
The Hebrew reads יוֹצֵר אוֹר וּבוֹרֵא חֹשֶׁךְ עֹשֶׂה שָׁלוֹם וּבוֹרֵא רָע (yotser or u-vore choshekh, oseh shalom u-vore ra). Ra can mean evil, harm, calamity or adversity. Here it contrasts with שָׁלוֹם (shalom), peace and well-being, and refers to God's sovereignty over historical adversity, not divine moral wickedness. The Septuagint has ποιῶν εἰρήνην καὶ κτίζων κακά (poiōn eirēnēn kai ktizōn kaka), making peace and creating calamities. James 1:13 forbids calling God the author of sinful temptation. Do not use Isaiah to accuse disaster victims.
4. The philosophical problem of evil
The logical problem asks whether evil contradicts an omnipotent, perfectly good God. The evidential problem asks whether the amount and apparently pointless character of suffering counts against God's existence. A free-will defense may address some logical objections, but does not resolve all natural suffering. Orthodox faith offers no complete explanation of each tragedy. God's providence can redeem evil without making evil good; Romans 8:28 is not a claim that every tragedy was divinely planned.
5. Job: the righteous suffer
Job 1:1 describes a righteous man who suffers severe loss. His friends wrongly infer secret guilt from suffering, and God rebukes them in Job 42:7. Job laments, questions and seeks God. God's speeches in Job 38–42 show the limits of human knowledge rather than furnishing a detailed explanation of each loss. A grieving person needs compassion, not a search for hidden sins.
6. Jesus rejects blaming victims
In John 9:1–3 the disciples ask whether the man born blind or his parents sinned. Jesus rejects that proposed explanation: οὔτε οὗτος ἥμαρτεν οὔτε οἱ γονεῖς αὐτοῦ (oute houtos hēmarten oute hoi goneis autou). The punctuation and connection of the following clause to verse 4 are debated; do not claim God caused blindness merely to stage a miracle. In Luke 13:1–5 Jesus rejects the idea that those killed by Pilate or by the tower of Siloam were worse sinners. Luke 13:10–17 presents healing and dignity, not accusation.
7. Jesus wept: John 11
John 11:35 says ἐδάκρυσεν ὁ Ἰησοῦς (edakrysen ho Iēsous), Jesus wept. The incarnate Word experiences real human grief even though He will raise Lazarus. John 11:33 uses language of deep emotional agitation, whose precise nuance is debated. Christ's tears reveal compassion; His command to Lazarus reveals life-giving authority. Grief is not a failure of faith.
8. Romans 8: creation groans
Romans 8:22 says πᾶσα ἡ κτίσις συστενάζει καὶ συνωδίνει (pasa hē ktisis systenazei kai synōdinei): all creation groans together and suffers birth pains. Κτίσις (ktisis) means creation; συστενάζει (systenazei), groans together; συνωδίνει (synōdinei), suffers birth pains together. Romans 8:26 says the Spirit helps our weakness, using συναντιλαμβάνεται (synantilambanetai), coming to our aid. Romans 8:28 affirms divine work toward good, not that every evil event is good. Romans 8:38–39 promises nothing can separate us from God's love in Christ.
9. St. Basil: God is not the cause of evil
St. Basil the Great, Homily That God Is Not the Cause of Evil (often numbered Homily 9), distinguishes moral evil from painful adversity and judgment. Evil choices arise from misuse of freedom, not God's moral wickedness. His fourth-century discussion of corrective discipline cannot be used to pronounce a child's illness or a disaster a particular punishment. The goodness of God is the theological starting point.
10. St. Gregory of Nyssa: privation
In The Great Catechism, chapters 5–8, St. Gregory explains evil not as an independent substance equal to God but as a deprivation or distortion of good. Injustice corrupts right relationship; hatred distorts love. This metaphysical account does not make actual suffering imaginary and does not explain the occurrence of each natural disaster.
11. St. Athanasius: healing corruption
In On the Incarnation, especially chapters 4–10 and 20–27, Athanasius describes humanity's movement toward corruption and death and the Word's saving assumption of humanity. Redemption is renewal, healing and victory over death, not merely an external legal verdict. The Creator acts to restore His creation.
12. St. Cyril: the Word suffered in the flesh
In his Third Letter to Nestorius, Anathema 12, Cyril confesses τὸν τοῦ θεοῦ λόγον παθόντα σαρκὶ (ton tou theou logon pathonta sarki), the Word of God suffered in the flesh. The one incarnate Son experiences real human pain without His divine nature becoming mortal. The Cross reveals God's self-giving response to suffering; it does not explain the cause of each tragedy. See also On the Unity of Christ and Commentary on John.
13. St. Severus and St. Isaac
St. Severus of Antioch, in his Letters and Cathedral Homilies, maintains the one incarnate Christ and the reality of His human suffering. The divine nature remains immortal; the Word's assumed humanity truly suffers. St. Isaac of Nineveh, historically of the Church of the East and later widely received across Eastern Christianity, teaches a merciful heart compassionate toward people, animals and creation in his Ascetical Homilies. Do not inaccurately identify him as a historical Malankara bishop.
14. Oriental Orthodox Christology
St. Cyril's μία φύσις τοῦ θεοῦ λόγου σεσαρκωμένη (mia physis tou Theou Logou sesarkōmenē) confesses one incarnate nature of God the Word. The Malankara Orthodox tradition affirms Christ fully divine and fully human, without confusion or personal division. The incarnate Son truly suffers in His humanity. The Cross does not make suffering good; it manifests divine love confronting suffering and death.
15. Punishment and temptation
Job, John 9 and Luke 13 refute the assumption that all suffering punishes individual sin. Hebrews 12 discusses discipline but does not authorize assigning each tragedy to God's punitive intent. James 1:13 says ὁ γὰρ θεὸς ἀπείραστός ἐστιν κακῶν, πειράζει δὲ αὐτὸς οὐδένα: God is not tempted by evil and tempts no one. The verb πειράζω (peirazō) can mean test or tempt depending on context; James distinguishes endurance in trials from temptation toward sin. Never tell grieving parents God killed their child to test them.
16. The Cross and Resurrection
Romans 5:8 presents Christ's self-giving death as divine love. The Cross does not offer a causal explanation for every earthquake or murder, but shows the incarnate Son entering suffering. First Corinthians 15:20–26 names death the final enemy and proclaims Christ's resurrection victory. Christian disciples must oppose injustice, feed the hungry, visit the sick and care for the vulnerable (Matthew 25:31–46).
17. Revelation 21: renewal
Revelation 21:4 promises ἐξαλείψει πᾶν δάκρυον (exaleipsei pan dakryon), He will wipe away every tear. The hope is bodily resurrection and a renewed creation (Romans 8:21; 1 Corinthians 15; Revelation 21–22), not denial of grief or escape from matter. God will overcome death, mourning and pain.
18. Holy Qurbana
The Holy Qurbana celebrates the saving Incarnation, Cross and Resurrection, not suffering as an end in itself. Eucharistic thanksgiving (εὐχαριστία, eucharistia) is compatible with lament and prayer for healing. The Church prays for the suffering, the living and the departed. First Corinthians 11:17–34 condemns worship that neglects or humiliates members of the community. Communion should lead to reconciliation, generosity and protection of the vulnerable.
19. Pastoral care
Listen before explaining. Offer presence, not false certainty. Help with meals, transport, medical care and practical needs. Protect people experiencing abuse; forgiveness never requires remaining in danger. Offer prayer, Holy Qurbana, confession or Holy Unction as appropriate and welcomed, alongside rather than instead of professional care. Psalms 13 and 22 and Job show that lament and questions can be expressions of faith. A compassionate response is: 'I do not know why this happened. Jesus Himself wept. We can grieve, pray and seek support together.'
20. Twelve objections and answers
1. Why not stop every evil act? Human freedom has consequences, but does not explain every tragedy. 2. Does Isaiah 45:7 make God wicked? No; ra here concerns calamity in context. 3. Does ancestral sin cause each illness? No particular causal attribution is warranted. 4. Why do children suffer? No complete explanation; never blame children. 5. Is cancer divine punishment? No such inference is justified. 6. Why disasters? Natural processes can cause harm; do not invent divine motives. 7. Does everything happen for a reason? Providence can redeem evil without making it good. 8. Why not heal everyone who prays? No guarantee of immediate cure; continue medical and pastoral care. 9. Is suffering necessary for growth? Sometimes growth occurs, but trauma can also devastate. 10. Why do the wicked prosper? Psalm 73 acknowledges the question. 11. Why does evil remain after Christ? Final victory awaits resurrection and renewal. 12. Can doubters pray? Yes; lament belongs within Scripture.
21. Seven-day reflection
Day 1: Genesis 1:26–31, thank God for creation. Day 2: Job 1–2 and 42:7, accompany a sufferer without blame. Day 3: John 9:1–7, repent of judgmental assumptions. Day 4: John 11:32–44, bring grief to Christ. Day 5: Romans 8:18–39, pray for the sick and creation. Day 6: Matthew 25:31–46, perform an act of mercy. Day 7: Revelation 21:1–5, pray in resurrection hope.
22. Group discussion questions
1. How can God be good when evil exists? 2. How do moral and natural evil differ? 3. What does Genesis mean by good creation? 4. What does Hebrew ra mean in Isaiah 45:7? 5. Why is free will an incomplete theodicy? 6. What do Job's friends get wrong? 7. How does John 9 address disability? 8. Why did Jesus weep? 9. What does Basil mean by God not causing evil? 10. What is Gregory's privation account? 11. How does Athanasius connect corruption and Incarnation? 12. What does Cyril's Christology contribute? 13. Why avoid saying God planned every tragedy? 14. What does creation's groaning mean? 15. How does Qurbana shape compassion? 16. How should clergy comfort bereaved families? 17. How is acceptance different from tolerating injustice? 18. How does resurrection transform death? 19. How can parishes heal rather than judge? 20. What does Revelation 21:4 promise?
23. Historical sources and reading
Scripture: Genesis 1–3; Job 1–2 and 38–42; Isaiah 45:7; John 9 and 11; Luke 13; Romans 8; James 1; Revelation 21–22. Fathers: Basil the Great, That God Is Not the Cause of Evil (Homily 9); Gregory of Nyssa, The Great Catechism 5–8; Athanasius, On the Incarnation 4–10 and 20–27; Cyril of Alexandria, Third Letter to Nestorius, Anathema 12, and On the Unity of Christ; Severus of Antioch, Letters and Cathedral Homilies; Isaac of Nineveh, Ascetical Homilies. Primary reading: https://www.newadvent.org/fathers/2903.htm ; https://www.newadvent.org/fathers/2802.htm ; https://www.ccel.org/ccel/pearse/morefathers/files/severus_coll_3_letters.htm ; https://www.fourthcentury.com/cyril-ep-17-third-letter-to-nestorius-with-12-anathemas-cpg-5317/ . Compare critical editions and reliable translations; do not treat paraphrases as verbatim quotations.
24. Conclusion and prayer
God created the world good and is not morally evil. Freedom, mortality, corruption and the world's natural processes contribute to suffering, but no formula explains every tragedy. The Church refuses to blame victims. In Christ, God enters suffering and defeats death; in the Spirit, He sustains those who grieve; in the promised resurrection, He will make all things new. Lord Jesus Christ, comfort the grieving, strengthen the weak, protect the vulnerable and teach us to resist injustice with compassionate love. Grant hope in Your resurrection, and glory to You with the Father and the Holy Spirit forever. Amen.
FROM THE ORTHODOX TV ARCHIVE
Love God & Love Life.
PASS IT ON
Share this reflection.
