LISTEN · കേൾക്കാം
Listen to this article
English audio for this article is not available yet.
100 Orthodox Believer Questions — Question 6
Rev. Fr. Johnson Punchakonam
The central question and Orthodox answer
If God already knows our thoughts, needs and future, why pray? Prayer is not information delivered to an uninformed deity. It is communion with the Father through the incarnate Son in the Holy Spirit: worship, repentance, thanksgiving, petition and intercession. Yet prayer is not merely psychological self-improvement: Scripture teaches that God truly hears and acts. God's foreknowledge need not eliminate the meaningful participation of free human beings in His providence.
Matthew 6:8: God knows before we ask
Jesus says, οἶδεν γὰρ ὁ πατὴρ ὑμῶν ὧν χρείαν ἔχετε πρὸ τοῦ ὑμᾶς αἰτῆσαι αὐτόν (oiden gar ho patēr hymōn hōn chreian echete pro tou hymas aitēsai auton): your Father knows what you need before you ask. οἶδεν (oiden) means knows; πατήρ (patēr), father; χρεία (chreia), need; αἰτῆσαι (aitēsai), to ask; πρὸ τοῦ (pro tou), before. Jesus immediately teaches the Lord's Prayer (Matthew 6:9–13). Prior knowledge therefore does not cancel prayer. Matthew 6:7 criticizes βατταλογέω (battalogeō), commonly interpreted as empty babbling, not all repetition: Jesus repeats His own prayer in Matthew 26:44.
The Lord's Prayer and the Greek epiousios
Πάτερ ἡμῶν ὁ ἐν τοῖς οὐρανοῖς (Pater hēmōn ho en tois ouranois) means Our Father in heaven. 'Our' makes prayer communal. The petitions seek God's holy name, kingdom and will; daily bread; forgiveness; protection in temptation; deliverance from evil. Matthew 6:11 uses ἐπιούσιος (epiousios) for the bread requested; this rare word's precise meaning is disputed: daily, necessary for existence, or for the coming day are among proposals. Eucharistic readings are later theological applications, not a certain lexical definition. The Father knows our need for bread, yet asks us to seek it in trust and solidarity with the hungry.
Foreknowledge, freedom and providence
Foreknowledge is not identical with coercion. Knowing a choice is not by itself causing the choice, although God's infallible knowledge raises a real philosophical difficulty beyond human prediction. Orthodox theology upholds divine omniscience and real moral responsibility without claiming an easy metaphysical solution. God's providence can include freely offered prayers and actions. Acts 12:5–17 portrays the Church praying for imprisoned Peter and his deliverance, without promising identical outcomes for every prisoner. Exodus 32:9–14, Jonah 3:10 and 2 Kings 20:1–6 portray God responding within history; Numbers 23:19 and Malachi 3:6 proclaim His faithfulness. God's responsiveness need not mean He learned new facts or corrected an error.
Synergy: grace and human participation
Greek συνεργία (synergia) means cooperation or working together. Related biblical language occurs in 1 Corinthians 3:9 and James 2:22, although later theological usage is broader. Philippians 2:12–13 holds together the believer's active response and God's working within the believer to will and act. Grace precedes and sustains the human response; salvation is not earned by unaided effort. Prayer is free participation in divine life, not control over divine power. Prayer for the hungry should inspire feeding them; prayer for peace should inspire peacemaking.
Why Jesus prayed: Oriental Orthodox Christology
Luke 5:16, 6:12, John 17 and Matthew 26:39 describe Christ praying. The eternal Son, fully divine, assumed genuine humanity. The one incarnate Word prays according to His humanity, in communion with the distinct Person of the Father; His prayer does not imply inferior divinity or a second independent human person. In Gethsemane He prays in genuine anguish and obediently submits to the Father's will. The Trinity does not have rival divine purposes. Christ's own prayer shows that prayer belongs to a life of loving communion, not merely to ignorance.
Luke 11: ask, seek and knock
Luke 11:9 reads αἰτεῖτε καὶ δοθήσεται ὑμῖν· ζητεῖτε καὶ εὑρήσετε· κρούετε καὶ ἀνοιγήσεται ὑμῖν (aiteite kai dothēsetai hymin; zēteite kai heurēsete; krouete kai anoigēsetai hymin). αἰτεῖτε means ask; ζητεῖτε seek; κρούετε knock. These present imperatives describe characteristic or ongoing action in context, not a magical number of repetitions. Luke 11:13 focuses on the Father's gift of the Holy Spirit. Petition rests on God's goodness, not a promise that every desired object must be supplied.
Luke 18: persistent widow
Luke 18:1–8 explicitly teaches continual prayer and not losing heart. An unjust judge finally responds to a widow's pursuit of justice. The argument contrasts that judge with the just God; God is not reluctant or exhausted by repeated petitions. Persistence embodies faith and the search for justice, but it is not a formula to force a particular outcome. The parable closes by asking whether the Son of Man will find faith on earth.
Romans 8: the Spirit intercedes
Romans 8:26 says τὸ πνεῦμα συναντιλαμβάνεται τῇ ἀσθενείᾳ ἡμῶν (to pneuma synantilambanetai tē astheneia hēmōn): the Spirit helps our weakness. συναντιλαμβάνεται suggests coming to another's aid. ὑπερεντυγχάνει (hyperentynchanei) means intercedes on behalf. We sometimes do not know how to pray; the Spirit helps us. Ephesians 2:18 expresses access to the Father through Christ in one Spirit. Silence, tears and brief prayers for mercy can be real prayer, not evidence of spiritual failure.
Intercessory prayer in Scripture
Abraham intercedes in Genesis 18:22–33; Moses in Exodus 32:11–14; Job prays for friends in Job 42:8–10; Christ prays for Peter in Luke 22:31–32; the Church prays for Peter in Acts 12:5; Paul asks prayer in Romans 15:30; James 5:14–16 directs the elders to pray for the sick. First Timothy 2:1 names δεήσεις, προσευχάς, ἐντεύξεις, εὐχαριστίας (deēseis, proseuchas, enteuxeis, eucharistias): supplications, prayers, intercessions and thanksgivings, with overlapping meanings. We intercede because love involves solidarity and participation in God's concern, not because God needs to be informed.
Christ's unique mediation and the saints
First Timothy 2:5 confesses Christ as the one Mediator of salvation. Orthodox requests for the saints' intercession do not posit rival redeemers. James 5:16 encourages mutual prayer; Romans 8:38–39 affirms that death cannot separate believers from Christ's love; Hebrews 12:1 speaks of witnesses; Revelation 5:8 and 8:3–4 link heavenly worship with prayers. These passages contribute to, but do not individually establish every detail of, later devotional practice. Worship belongs to the Holy Trinity alone; the saints are honored as members of Christ's Body.
St. Cyril of Alexandria on prayer
St. Cyril's Commentary on Luke, especially Sermons 70–79 on Luke 11, expounds prayer as a privilege of divine sonship. Calling God Father entails holiness, repentance and loving conduct. Cyril urges persistence and explains that a loving Father gives what is truly beneficial, not necessarily everything demanded. His interpretation of the incarnate Son's prayer protects the Son's divinity and genuine humanity. These are paraphrases of Cyril's themes, not verbatim quotations. Primary reading: https://catholiclibrary.org/library/view?chunk.id=00000007&docId=Fathers-EN%2FCyril.OnLuke.en.html
St. Ephrem the Syrian and prayer of the heart
St. Ephrem (c. 306–373) employs poetry, biblical images, praise, humility and repentance in the Hymns on Faith and Nisibene Hymns. His spirituality emphasizes heartfelt supplication, not words alone. The Nisibene Hymns voice communal fear, sorrow and hope: prayer belongs even amid suffering. The West Syriac tradition's psalms, hymns, fasting, bodily reverence and liturgical hours integrate the heart and the worshipping community. Primary reading: https://adfonteslibrary.org/work-ephrem-nisibene-hymns
St. Jacob of Serugh and the Lord's Prayer
St. Jacob of Serugh (c. 451–521) composed a Syriac metrical homily (memra) on the Lord's Prayer, published in Paul Bedjan's selected homilies, volume 1 (1905), and translated into English by Morgan Reed (2016). It explores approaching God as Father and the communal petitions for God's kingdom, bread, forgiveness and deliverance. 'Our Father' obliges concern for neighbors; prayer for bread should remember the hungry, and prayer for forgiveness demands a forgiving life. Historical text: https://thesermonarchive.org/sermons/jacob-of-serug/on-the-prayer-that-our-lord-taught-to-his-disciples-our-father-which-art-in-heav/
St. Severus of Antioch and prayer
St. Severus (c. 465–538), central to the West Syriac and Malankara theological inheritance, defends the unity of the incarnate Word. The one Christ genuinely prays in His assumed humanity; prayer is communion through the incarnate Son. His Letters and Cathedral Homilies illuminate Christology and worship. Do not attribute to Severus a detailed modern philosophical solution to foreknowledge and petitionary prayer without a specifically verified passage. Selected letters: https://www.ccel.org/ccel/pearse/morefathers/files/severus_coll_3_letters.htm
Historical witnesses and liturgical development
Acts 2:42 records the apostolic community's devotion to prayers and breaking bread. Didache 8, generally dated to the late first or early second century, prescribes reciting the Lord's Prayer three times daily; exact dating remains debated. Origen's On Prayer (third century) addresses petition and divine knowledge; Cyprian's On the Lord's Prayer stresses the community. Ephrem, Cyril, Jacob and Severus witness later Syriac and Alexandrian development. The Malankara Church inherits West Syriac daily offices, psalms, litanies and Eucharistic worship; traditional attribution of the St. James Anaphora does not mean every word was written personally by the apostle.
Holy Qurbana: prayer of the whole Church
The Holy Qurbana is the Church's common thanksgiving, remembrance, offering and intercession in Christ, not merely individuals praying side by side. The priest, deacons and faithful participate according to their liturgical roles. ἀναφορά (anaphora) means offering or lifting up and denotes the central Eucharistic prayer. ἐπίκλησις (epiklēsis) is invocation, especially of the Holy Spirit. The Church prays for living and departed and praises the Father, Son and Holy Spirit. First Corinthians 11:17–34 condemns worship that humiliates neighbors. Eucharistic prayer should lead to reconciliation, charity and service.
When prayers seem unanswered
A parent may pray and still lose a child; a patient may pray without recovering. Do not accuse them of inadequate faith. In 2 Corinthians 12:7–10 Paul repeatedly pleads for relief yet receives the promise of sufficient grace rather than the requested removal. Christ's Gethsemane prayer is genuine, not weak faith. The popular formula 'yes, no, or wait' is not a direct biblical quotation and may trivialize pain. The Psalms permit lament; prayer for healing should accompany appropriate medical treatment, not replace it. A priest may honestly say: 'I do not know why this happened. We can grieve, pray and seek support together.'
Twelve objections and answers
1. Why ask when God knows? Communion, not information (Matthew 6:8–9). 2. Can prayer change God's plan? Scripture describes genuine divine response; no new divine ignorance is implied. 3. Is freedom compatible with foreknowledge? Foreknowledge is not coercion, though the issue is philosophically difficult. 4. Why pray for healing? Love and providential participation, without guaranteed cure. 5. Why divine silence? Lament is scriptural; do not invent motives. 6. Does repetition force an answer? No; faithful repetition differs from empty babbling. 7. Why saints? Their intercession depends wholly on Christ's unique mediation. 8. Does prayer replace action? No; feed the hungry and seek justice. 9. Why did Jesus pray? Genuine humanity of the one incarnate Word. 10. Can emotionless prayer count? Yes. 11. Can I pray without a priest? Yes, personal prayer is essential. 12. Is Qurbana more than prayers? Yes, Eucharistic participation in Christ's saving mystery.
A practical Orthodox prayer rule
Morning: sign of the Cross, Trisagion, Lord's Prayer, offer the day to God. Scripture: read a Gospel or Psalm passage. Intercession: pray for family, sick, departed, Church and those in need. Midday: pause to seek wisdom. Evening: give thanks, examine conscience, seek forgiveness. Weekly: participate in Holy Qurbana as circumstances allow. A spiritual father can adapt the rule to health, age and family responsibilities. A short attentive prayer is better than an unmanageable rule performed resentfully.
Twenty group discussion questions
1. Why pray if God knows? 2. How is prayer different from information? 3. Explain Matthew 6:8. 4. Why 'Our Father'? 5. Why does God's kingdom precede our requests? 6. What does epiousios mean? 7. Does foreknowledge eliminate freedom? 8. Distinguish knowledge and coercion. 9. What is synergy? 10. Why did Jesus pray in Gethsemane? 11. Explain ask, seek and knock. 12. Why does Luke 11 promise the Spirit? 13. What does the widow teach? 14. How does the Spirit intercede? 15. Why pray for others? 16. What does Cyril teach? 17. How does Ephrem enrich prayer? 18. What is Jacob's Lord's Prayer homily? 19. How does Qurbana express communal prayer? 20. How should the Church respond to unanswered prayer?
Conclusion and closing prayer
Prayer is not information transfer or manipulation. God knows our needs, yet invites His children to ask. The Father receives prayer, the incarnate Son opens communion, and the Spirit helps our weakness. Prayer and free responsible action participate in providence. In the Holy Qurbana the whole Church offers thanksgiving and intercession. Lord our God, Father, Son and Holy Spirit, teach us to pray humbly and persistently. Comfort those whose petitions seem unanswered, heal and strengthen the sick, protect the vulnerable, unite us in Your Church, and make our prayers bear fruit in compassionate action. To You be glory now and forever. Amen.
FROM THE ORTHODOX TV ARCHIVE
Love God & Love Life.
PASS IT ON
Share this reflection.
