Rooted in tradition. Connected in faith.Englishമലയാളം
Bible StudyTheology

Can a Faithful Christian Have Doubts? — Malankara Orthodox Bible Study

LISTEN · കേൾക്കാം

Listen to this article

English audio for this article is not available yet.

100 Orthodox Believer Questions — Question 8

Rev. Fr. Johnson Punchakonam

Opening: Can a faithful Christian have doubts?

Doubt can mean an honest question, uncertainty, fear, or deliberate rejection; these are not interchangeable. Scripture does not command believers to pretend that difficult questions do not exist. Faith is a relationship of trust in the living God, sustained by grace, the Church, worship, and thoughtful examination. A person struggling to understand the Trinity, suffering, or prayer should not automatically be accused of apostasy.

Mark 9:24: faith and unbelief together

The father of a suffering child cries, 'I believe; help my unbelief!' The Greek πιστεύω (pisteuō) means 'I believe/trust'; ἀπιστία (apistia) can mean unbelief or lack of faith. The text joins a genuine confession with a plea for help. Jesus responds compassionately rather than demanding that the father first achieve perfect psychological certainty. The scene is not a guarantee that every prayer for healing will receive the same outcome.

John 20:24–29: Thomas and the risen Christ

Thomas asks for evidence concerning the Resurrection. The Greek phrase μὴ γίνου ἄπιστος ἀλλὰ πιστός (mē ginou apistos alla pistos) means 'Do not become unbelieving, but believing/faithful.' The risen Jesus invites Thomas to encounter His wounds. Thomas answers 'My Lord and my God!' (ὁ κύριός μου καὶ ὁ θεός μου). Jesus blesses those who believe without having seen, not those who abandon reason or disregard testimony. In the Malankara tradition St. Thomas is also honored as the apostle associated with the origins of Christianity in India; historical traditions should be distinguished from claims directly established by the New Testament.

Matthew 11:2–6: John the Baptist's question

From prison John sends disciples to ask whether Jesus is the expected One. Jesus points to the signs of His ministry, echoing Isaiah's restoration imagery. John's question has been interpreted differently by Church Fathers: some read it as instruction for his disciples rather than personal doubt. The narrative nonetheless shows Jesus answering with scriptural witness, not mere ridicule. Avoid claiming certainty about John's private psychological state.

Psalm 73 and Habakkuk: intellectual and moral struggle

Psalm 73 wrestles with the prosperity of the wicked; Habakkuk 1 asks why injustice continues. Hebrew אֱמוּנָה (ʾemunah) in Habakkuk 2:4 carries faithfulness or steadfastness. Honest questions about injustice can lead to prayer, reflection and action. The Bible distinguishes lament addressed to God from a settled decision to abandon Him.

Greek analysis: faith, doubt and examination

πίστις (pistis) can denote faith, trust, fidelity; πιστεύω (pisteuō) is to believe or trust. διστάζω (distazō), used in Matthew 14:31 and 28:17, means hesitate or doubt. διακρίνω (diakrinō) has multiple senses, including distinguish and doubt, depending on context (James 1:6). δοκιμάζω (dokimazō) means test or examine (1 Thessalonians 5:21). Lexical meaning depends on grammar and setting; these terms cannot all be reduced to one English notion of doubt.

Faith and reason in Orthodox theology

Orthodoxy rejects both proud rationalism that demands complete mastery of God and fideism that forbids thoughtful inquiry. The Nicene Creed is a communal confession grounded in apostolic Scripture and the Church's discernment, not a substitute for careful reading. God's divine essence transcends human comprehension, while the Incarnation reveals God truly. Mystery is not an excuse for contradictions, deception or suppressing legitimate questions.

St. Cyril of Alexandria: Christ and the confession of Thomas

In his Commentary on John, St. Cyril treats Thomas's confession as a witness to the risen Christ's divine identity and bodily Resurrection. The one incarnate Word is not divided into separate personal subjects. Cyril's approach joins the scriptural narrative to the Church's confession. This is a theological summary, not a purported verbatim quotation; consult the Commentary on John, Book XII, on John 20.

St. Ephrem the Syrian: wonder and the limits of knowledge

St. Ephrem's Hymns on Faith explore divine mystery through scriptural poetry, paradox and reverent wonder. Human knowledge is real but finite. Ephrem does not encourage contempt for learning; he cautions against trying to confine God within human concepts. Distinguish these interpretive themes from direct quotation; translations and numbering of the hymns vary by edition.

St. Jacob of Serugh and St. Severus

St. Jacob's Syriac metrical homilies invite believers to contemplate the Incarnation and Scripture with wonder. St. Severus of Antioch's letters defend the unity of the incarnate Christ against division into two personal subjects. These fathers provide theological foundations for thoughtful Christian confession; neither should be falsely quoted as having authored a modern psychological theory of doubt. Primary sources: Jacob's published homilies and Severus's Letters.

Historical witness: Nicaea and the apostolic faith

Nicaea (325) addressed controversy over the Son's relation to the Father, confessing the Son as begotten not made and of one essence with the Father. Constantinople (381) clarified the Church's Trinitarian confession. The Malankara Orthodox Syrian Church receives the first three ecumenical councils, including Ephesus (431), and confesses the one incarnate Word. Councils show that doctrinal questions have been examined seriously; their historical disputes should not be caricatured as a vote that invented Christ's divinity.

Kinds of doubt and their pastoral response

Intellectual questions benefit from study and conversation. Emotional doubt may accompany grief or trauma and needs compassionate listening. Scrupulosity and intrusive religious fears may need mental-health assessment; do not impose endless rituals. Deliberate rejection and honest uncertainty are distinct. A spiritual father should ask what the person means before offering judgment, and should respect conscience and safety.

Holy Qurbana: faith sustained in community

In the Holy Qurbana the Church confesses the faith, hears Scripture, offers thanksgiving, commemorates Christ's saving work and invokes the Holy Spirit. The Eucharist is not an exam requiring absolute emotional certainty. Participation and sacramental discipline are guided by the Church's pastoral practice; questions about Communion should be discussed with one's priest rather than answered with blanket permission or exclusion.

Objections and answers

1. Is doubt always sin? No; distinguish inquiry, temptation and deliberate repudiation. 2. Was Thomas condemned? Jesus called him to faith and received his confession. 3. Must I understand the Trinity completely? No created mind comprehends God's essence. 4. Can I ask about Church history? Yes; use primary sources and careful methods. 5. Does science disprove faith? Scientific and theological questions overlap in some areas but are not identical. 6. What if prayers feel unanswered? See Psalms 13 and 88; avoid false certainty. 7. Is every teaching equally negotiable? No; distinguish apostolic dogma, discipline and local custom. 8. Can children ask questions? Yes; respond without ridicule. 9. What if clergy fail? Clergy misconduct must not be excused; pursue safeguarding and accountability. 10. Should I stop worshipping until all doubts disappear? Seek pastoral guidance; prayer and inquiry can continue together. 11. Can anxiety mimic doubt? Yes, and professional help may be appropriate. 12. What if I cannot believe? Speak honestly, seek trustworthy support and avoid coerced declarations.

Group discussion: 15 questions

1. How do you define doubt? 2. What does Mark 9:24 teach? 3. Why does Thomas ask for evidence? 4. What does his confession mean? 5. How does Jesus respond to John's question? 6. What is the difference between pistis and distazō? 7. What does Habakkuk teach about injustice? 8. What are the limits of reason? 9. What does Cyril teach about the risen Christ? 10. How does Ephrem use wonder? 11. What did Nicaea actually address? 12. How should parents answer children's questions? 13. How can spiritual dryness affect belief? 14. How does Holy Qurbana sustain faith? 15. What practical support should the parish offer questioners?

Scripture and patristic documentation

Scripture: Mark 9:14–29; John 20:24–29; Matthew 11:2–6; Matthew 14:22–33; Matthew 28:16–20; Psalm 73; Habakkuk 1–3; James 1:5–8; 1 Thessalonians 5:21; 1 Peter 3:15. Patristic reading: Cyril of Alexandria, Commentary on John, Book XII; Ephrem the Syrian, Hymns on Faith; Jacob of Serugh, selected metrical homilies; Severus of Antioch, Letters. Historical documents: Nicene Creed (325), Constantinopolitan Creed (381), Council of Ephesus (431). Verify individual patristic quotations against scholarly editions; this article paraphrases their themes.

Conclusion and prayer

Christian faith is neither unthinking certainty nor endless skepticism. The father in Mark 9 prays, 'I believe; help my unbelief'; Thomas meets the risen Lord and confesses Him. Questions should be brought into prayer, Scripture, the worshipping Church and honest conversation. Lord Jesus Christ, receive those who seek You through fear and uncertainty. Grant humility to teachers, patience to families, integrity to clergy and courage to those who ask. Strengthen us in the Holy Spirit and unite us in Your truth and love. Amen.

FROM THE ORTHODOX TV ARCHIVE

Love God & Love Life.

Original publication

PASS IT ON

Share this reflection.

Email