LISTEN · കേൾക്കാം
Listen to this article
English audio for this article is not available yet.
100 Orthodox Believer Questions — Question 7
Rev. Fr. Johnson Punchakonam
Introduction: when heaven seems silent
A mother prays for her sick child, a family seeks reconciliation, a faithful worshipper experiences spiritual emptiness. Why does God seem silent? Scripture does not dismiss this question. David, Job, Habakkuk and even Christ on the Cross give voice to anguish. The Malankara Orthodox Church does not teach that every unanswered prayer is punishment or weak faith. Apparent silence does not necessarily mean divine absence, but we must not pretend to know God's reason for every tragedy.
What divine silence means
Distinguish unanswered petition, delayed response, spiritual dryness, hiddenness, suffering and moral confusion. A believer may not feel God's presence while continuing to live in faith. Psalm 139:7–12 describes divine presence even in darkness; Romans 8:38–39 says creation cannot separate us from God's love in Christ. Emotional experience and theological reality are not identical.
Psalm 13: Hebrew lament and covenant love
Psalm 13 repeats עַד־אָנָה (ʿad-ʾānāh), 'How long?' The verb שָׁכַח (shakhaḥ) means forget; פָּנִים (panim), face, can represent divine attention and favor. The psalmist speaks as though God has forgotten and hidden His face. Yet the poem moves from lament to petition to trust in חֶסֶד (ḥesed), steadfast covenant love, and praise. Scripture does not say every external problem was suddenly solved. Lament itself can be faithful prayer.
Psalm 22: the cry of abandonment
אֵלִי אֵלִי לָמָה עֲזַבְתָּנִי (ʾēlī ʾēlī lāmāh ʿazavtānī) means 'My God, my God, why have You forsaken me?' The verb עָזַב (ʿazav) means leave or forsake. The suffering psalmist still addresses God as 'my God.' The psalm moves from anguish and mockery to communal and worldwide praise. Both lament and hope are essential; its later praise should not erase the pain of its beginning.
Mark 15:34: did the Father abandon Jesus?
Jesus' Semitic cry 'Eloi, Eloi, lema sabachthani?' invokes Psalm 22. The eternal Word truly assumed complete humanity and suffered genuine anguish and death. The Holy Trinity was not broken or divided; the Father and Son did not cease to share the one divine life. The one incarnate Son speaks and suffers according to His humanity without becoming two independent personal subjects. Christ's suffering does not explain every tragedy but shows that the Savior has entered human anguish.
Job 23: the righteous cannot find God
Job searches in every direction yet cannot perceive God (Job 23:8–10). The book challenges the friends' simplistic claim that suffering must be punishment for particular sins; God rebukes their speech in Job 42:7. This does not mean every statement by Job is infallible doctrine. Pastoral application: never tell bereaved parents or patients that their suffering proves inadequate faith or hidden wrongdoing.
Habakkuk 1:2 and delayed justice
The Hebrew verb שָׁמַע (shamaʿ) means hear and sometimes heed. Habakkuk asks why violence and injustice appear unanswered. In Habakkuk 2:4 אֱמוּנָה (ʾemunah) conveys firmness, faithfulness or fidelity. Waiting on God is not indifference to exploitation: prayer for justice must be accompanied by truthful and responsible action.
Isaiah 45:15 and divine hiddenness
אֵל מִסְתַּתֵּר (ʾēl mistattēr) means 'a God who hides Himself'; the expression is related to סָתַר (satar), to conceal. Isaiah 45 concerns God's sovereignty and saving work within history. The verse does not say God enjoys causing confusion. Orthodox theology confesses that God transcends human comprehension yet truly reveals Himself through the prophets and supremely in Jesus Christ.
Greek words for perseverance and faith
ὑπομονή (hypomonē) denotes endurance or steadfastness (Romans 5:3–5). μακροθυμία (makrothymia) conveys patience or long-suffering (James 5:7–11). πίστις (pistis) can mean faith, trust or faithfulness depending on context. None means tolerating abuse or pretending suffering is painless. In Romans 8:26 the verb συναντιλαμβάνεται (synantilambanetai) describes the Spirit helping our weakness when we do not know how to pray.
Holy Saturday: the silence of the tomb
On Holy Saturday Christ's body rests in the tomb while the disciples are afraid. Orthodox teaching proclaims Christ's victory over death and His descent into Hades, represented by the Anastasis icon raising Adam and Eve. First Peter 3:18–20 and Ephesians 4:8–10 have complex exegetical histories and should not be made to prove every iconographic detail. Holy Saturday does not guarantee a specific earthly miracle after every delay; Pascha proclaims that death does not have the final word.
St. Cyril of Alexandria
St. Cyril (c. 376–444) defends the unity of the incarnate Word in his Christological letters and biblical commentaries. The one Son genuinely suffers according to the humanity He assumed; His cry from the Cross does not mean the Trinity split apart. Cyril's Commentary on Luke, including Sermons 70–79 in the common English arrangement, emphasizes prayer to the Father, perseverance and beneficial petitions. These are theological paraphrases, not verbatim quotations. https://catholiclibrary.org/library/view?chunk.id=00000007&docId=Fathers-EN%2FCyril.OnLuke.en.html
St. Ephrem the Syrian and tears
St. Ephrem (c. 306–373) uses poetry, biblical imagery, repentance and praise to contemplate mystery. His Nisibene Hymns voice communal fear, distress and hope. The Syriac ܨܠܘܬܐ (ṣlōṯā) means prayer. Tears and brief cries for mercy can express heartfelt prayer, although crying is not a required proof of spirituality. The Syriac tradition joins psalms, hymns, fasting, bodily reverence and the community's worship. https://adfonteslibrary.org/work-ephrem-nisibene-hymns
St. Jacob of Serugh
St. Jacob (c. 451–521) composed metrical Syriac homilies (memre), including a homily on the Lord's Prayer. The work appears in Paul Bedjan's edition of selected homilies (volume 1, 1905) and was translated by Morgan Reed (2016). Addressing God as 'Our Father' grounds prayer in communion and responsibility for neighbors. Praying for bread should encourage feeding the hungry, and praying for forgiveness should inspire reconciliation. These are theological applications, not alleged direct quotations. https://thesermonarchive.org/sermons/jacob-of-serug/on-the-prayer-that-our-lord-taught-to-his-disciples-our-father-which-art-in-heav/
St. Severus of Antioch
St. Severus (c. 465–538) is a major West Syriac and Malankara theological witness. He defends the unity of the incarnate Word: Christ genuinely suffers in His assumed humanity without being divided into two persons. His Letters and Cathedral Homilies illuminate this Christological setting. It would be historically unjustified to claim that Severus supplied a specific modern theory explaining every episode of spiritual dryness. https://www.ccel.org/ccel/pearse/morefathers/files/severus_coll_3_letters.htm
Historical documentation
The Psalms, Job and Habakkuk preserve ancient Israel's prayers of lament. Acts 2:42 records early Christian devotion to prayers. Didache 8, often dated late first or early second century (exact dating disputed), prescribes the Lord's Prayer three times daily. Origen's On Prayer (third century) examines petition and divine knowledge; Cyprian writes on the Lord's Prayer. Ephrem, Cyril, Jacob and Severus witness Syriac and Alexandrian developments. West Syriac and Malankara worship inherits psalms, liturgical hours, litanies, fasting and Holy Qurbana. Historical continuity does not mean all later forms existed identically in apostolic times.
Spiritual dryness and depression
Spiritual dryness is diminished felt consolation during prayer, not automatically sin or loss of faith. Fatigue, grief, distraction, discouragement and changing expectations can contribute. It can coexist with clinical depression, but they are not identical. Persistent hopelessness, impaired functioning, sleep changes or thoughts of self-harm warrant professional assessment and support. Priests should not automatically label such symptoms spiritual failure or demonic activity.
Five false conclusions to avoid
God's apparent silence does not automatically mean (1) God has stopped loving you (Romans 8:38–39); (2) you committed a hidden sin (Job; John 9); (3) your prayer was worthless (Romans 8:26); (4) more ritual effort will mechanically force a response (Matthew 6:7); or (5) you must remain in an abusive or dangerous situation. Christian endurance never cancels safeguarding or appropriate help.
Possible perspectives without false certainty
Luke 18 encourages perseverance; Job 38–42 exposes the limits of human understanding; Romans 8 describes prayer in weakness; Scripture recognizes human freedom and injustice. These perspectives can guide reflection but do not identify the specific reason for an individual's loss. A truthful pastoral response may be 'I do not know why this happened.' God's providence must not be invoked to excuse human wrongdoing.
Paul's thorn, Gethsemane and Psalm 88
In 2 Corinthians 12:7–10 Paul asks repeatedly for relief but receives assurance of sufficient grace rather than the requested removal; the thorn's precise nature is disputed. In Matthew 26:36–46 Jesus prays in genuine anguish. Psalm 88 ends in darkness without an explicit turn to joyful praise. Scripture therefore makes room for prayer without emotional resolution; faithful grief should not be silenced.
Holy Qurbana and the prayer of the Church
The Holy Qurbana is communal thanksgiving, remembrance, offering and intercession in Christ. When a grieving person has no words, the Church's priest, deacons, choir and faithful pray together. The Eucharistic ἐπίκλησις (epiklēsis) invokes the Holy Spirit. The Church prays for living and departed, remembers Christ's Cross and Resurrection, and offers hope not dependent on emotional intensity. Great Lent, Holy Week, Holy Saturday and Pascha teach the Church to pray through repentance, sorrow, waiting and joy.
Pastoral care: helpful words and harmful words
Helpful: 'I am here to listen'; 'You do not have to hide your grief'; 'We may not know why this happened'; 'May I pray with you?'; 'What support would help?' Harmful: 'Your faith is weak'; 'God is punishing you'; 'Everything happens for a reason'; 'Stop crying'; 'You do not need medical or psychological help.' Offer presence, practical assistance, confidentiality, safeguarding and referral when needed. Never use divine silence to justify coercion, violence or neglect.
A seven-part prayer rule
1. Morning: Cross and Lord's Prayer slowly. 2. Scripture: read Psalm 13, 42, 88 or a Gospel passage. 3. Mercy: 'Lord Jesus Christ, Son of God, have mercy on me.' 4. Intercession: name one suffering person. 5. Action: offer a concrete act of kindness or reconciliation. 6. Evening: thank God and entrust one sorrow to Him. 7. Sunday: participate in Holy Qurbana as circumstances permit. This is a suggested adaptable rhythm, not a mandatory liturgical rule.
Fifteen objections and answers
1. Why no answer? Love is not measured by a granted request. 2. Is God angry? Not necessarily; Job warns against blame. 3. Did the Father abandon Jesus? Christ's anguish is real; the Trinity was not divided. 4. Is asking 'why' sinful? No; biblical lament is prayer. 5. Why do the wicked prosper? Psalm 73 and Habakkuk address delayed justice. 6. Is dryness unbelief? Not necessarily. 7. Should I stop praying? Luke 18 encourages perseverance, not self-punishment. 8. Can I pray without feeling? Yes, Romans 8:26. 9. Does God cause every tragedy as a test? No such universal conclusion is warranted. 10. Why do children suffer? No simple explanation; protect and care for them. 11. Does unanswered prayer disprove God? It is a serious challenge, not a simple proof. 12. Can saints intercede? In Christ's Body, without replacing His unique mediation. 13. Why attend Qurbana without feeling? Its meaning does not depend on emotional intensity. 14. What to say to bereaved parents? Listen, avoid invented reasons, provide care. 15. Will every silence end with a miracle? Not promised; hope rests in the Resurrection.
Twenty group discussion questions
1. What is divine silence? 2. Unanswered prayer versus dryness? 3. Meaning of ʿad-ʾānāh? 4. How does Psalm 13 move toward trust? 5. What does Psalm 22 teach? 6. Was the Trinity divided on the Cross? 7. Why were Job's friends wrong? 8. What does Habakkuk say about injustice? 9. What does Isaiah 45:15 mean? 10. How does the Spirit help in Romans 8? 11. Perseverance versus passive resignation? 12. What does Cyril teach about the incarnate Son? 13. How does Ephrem's poetry express lament? 14. What is Jacob's teaching on prayer? 15. Why is Severus important? 16. What does Holy Saturday teach? 17. Why is dryness not always sin? 18. How should clergy respond? 19. How does Qurbana sustain believers? 20. What actions accompany intercession?
Sources and recommended reading
Scripture: Psalms 13, 22, 42–43, 73, 88; Job 23 and 38–42; Habakkuk 1–3; Isaiah 45:15; John 9:1–3; Luke 18:1–8; Mark 15:34; Romans 8:26–39; 2 Corinthians 12:7–10; Revelation 21:1–5. Patristic primary readings: Cyril, Commentary on Luke (link in section 11); Ephrem, Nisibene Hymns (section 12); Jacob, On the Lord's Prayer (section 13); Severus, Letters (section 14). For academic publication, verify particular patristic statements against critical editions with page and section references; paraphrases here are not verbatim citations.
Conclusion: Christ's presence amid unanswered questions
No single explanation fits every experience of silence. Grief, exhaustion, human wrongdoing and mystery can all be involved. Christian hope does not rest on God explaining each tragedy immediately, but on Jesus Christ crucified and risen. In Holy Qurbana the Church prays when our words fail; the Spirit helps our weakness; love becomes practical care. God's apparent silence is not proof of absence. Faith may bring unanswered questions to the crucified and risen Lord without pretending the pain is unreal.
Closing prayer
O Lord our God, Father, Son and Holy Spirit, You know the sorrows we cannot express. When we pray without an answer, grant patience without despair. When our hearts are dry, strengthen us through Your Spirit. Lord Jesus Christ, who suffered and cried upon the Cross, comfort the grieving, heal and strengthen the sick, protect the vulnerable and guide those struggling with doubt. Forgive careless explanations; teach us to listen, serve and love. Unite us in Holy Qurbana and the hope of Your Resurrection. To You be glory, now and forever. Amen.
FROM THE ORTHODOX TV ARCHIVE
Love God & Love Life.
PASS IT ON
Share this reflection.
